Contested Wills & Estate Litigation

Areas of Expertise: 

Yasmin McCann

Solicitor

LLB (Dist)

team-member-image
team-member-image
EXPERIENCE

Yasmin was admitted to practice in the Supreme Court of Western Australia in November 2022. She graduated with a Bachelor of Laws with Distinction from Murdoch University in 2021.

Prior to commencing at Williams + Hughes, Yasmin worked as an Associate to the Hon Justice Natalie Whitby at the District Court of Western Australia, and to the Hon Justice Marcus Solomon at the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

Yasmin is in our litigation team, and has a particular interest in contractual disputes, defamation and family provision claims.

Outside of law, Yasmin enjoys travelling, art and photography.

Yasmin is based in our West Perth office.
 

Williams + Hughes Earns Recertification in Meritas, the Leading Global Alliance of Independent Business Law Firms
Post by Damian Quail | Posted 3 years ago on Wednesday, May 12th, 2021

Williams + Hughes is pleased to announce that it has been awarded recertification in Meritas, a global alliance of independent business law firms. Williams + Hughes joined Meritas in 2014 and, as a condition of its membership, is required to successfully complete recertification every three years. 

Meritas is the only law firm alliance with an established and comprehensive means of monitoring the quality of its member firms, a process that saves clients’ time validating law firm credentials and experience. Meritas membership is selective and by invitation only. Firms are regularly assessed and recertified for the breadth of their practice expertise, client satisfaction and high standards of cybersecurity to keep legal information safe. Meritas’ extensive due diligence process ensures that only firms meeting the tenets of Meritas’ unique Quality Assurance Program are allowed to maintain membership. The measurement of the firm’s performance, based on input from clients, is reflected in a Satisfaction Index score, which is available online on the Meritas website.

“Our values of quality service and client satisfaction align with the Meritas mission to provide a safe and responsive global offering to clients,” said Damian Quail, Director. “We’ve successfully collaborated with colleagues in many jurisdictions around the world to solve client issues and help them seize opportunities outside of this market. We look forward to keeping those vital connections through membership in Meritas.”

The recertification process Williams + Hughes completed to maintain its membership status included exacting self-assessment, peer review by other law firms and client feedback.  

“Businesses trust the Meritas alliance of law firms for top-tier quality, convenience, consistency and value,” said Sona Pancholy, president of Meritas. “Williams + Hughes has demonstrated its commitment to world-class legal standards, and therefore has successfully earned its recertification in Meritas.”

For more information about our our membership in Meritas, please see here

About Meritas 

Meritas’ global alliance of independent, market-leading law firms provides borderless legal services to companies looking to effectively capture opportunities and solve issues anywhere in the world. Companies benefit from local knowledge, collective strength and new efficiencies when they work with Meritas law firms. The personal attention and care they experience is part of Meritas’ industry-first commitment to the utmost in quality of service and putting client priorities above all else. Founded in 1990, Meritas has member firms in 259 markets worldwide with more than 7,500 dedicated, collaborative lawyers. To locate a Meritas resource for a specific need or in a certain market, visit Meritas.org or call +1-612-339-8680

Meritas Welcomes DMAW Lawyers, Adelaide, to the Membership
Post by Damian Quail | Posted 4 years ago on Friday, July 17th, 2020

Leading Adelaide commercial Firm, DMAW Lawyers has been selected to be South Australia’s representative firm for Meritas, the premier global alliance of independent law firms.

DMAW Lawyers will become an integral part of the Australia & New Zealand network of firms as well as the worldwide network of 191 law firms located across 96 countries.

This alliance will enhance DMAW Lawyers’ ability to support South Australian business interests both nationally and internationally.

DMAW’s Lawyer’s Managing Director, Mr Leo Walsh said “One of most attractive benefits of belonging to this network was the opportunity for our lawyers to participate in national and global conversations on business and legal issues. Not only does this expand our thinking, and add to our technical skills, but it help our lawyers build trusted, reliable relationships with lawyers in the regions that matter to our clients. Already we’ve participated in meetings with Insolvency experts across the country and with Senior Partners in Shanghai and Tokyo.

Mr Mike Worsnop, Partner with Martelli McKegg in New Zealand and Co-Chair of Meritas ANZ: “We are delighted to have DMAW Lawyers join our group. Not only was their quality apparent but they’ve been very easy and responsive to deal with during our discussions.  They clearly demonstrated the type of service clients look for when using a firm in a different market.

DMAW Lawyers had to meet the rigorous requirements to become members of Meritas, the only law firm alliance with a Quality Assurance Program that ensures clients receive the same high-quality legal work and service from every Meritas firm.

Meritas membership is extended by invitation only, and firms are regularly assessed for the breadth of their practice expertise and client satisfaction.

Ms Sona Pancholy, Meritas CEO: “In today’s environment having a commitment to a reliable network is more important than ever. Independent law firms, Corporate Counsel, Business Owners and their Commercial Advisors, all choose their portfolio of trusted legal relationships to match the issues and the markets they want to navigate. For 30 years, Meritas has cultivated a group of the best firms for this purpose.

About DMAW Lawyers

DMAW Lawyers was established in Adelaide in 2002. The firm has ten Principals and a team of 50 staff. DMAW Lawyers focus on three areas of specialization being Corporate, Transactions, and Disputes for Business Clients.

Website: DMAW Lawyers

About Meritas

Founded in 1990, Meritas is the premier global alliance of independent law firms. As an invitation-only alliance, Meritas firms must adhere to uncompromising service standards to retain membership status. With 192 top-ranking law firms spanning 96 countries, Meritas delivers exceptional legal knowledge, personal attention and proven value to clients worldwide.  

Website:  Meritas 

In Australia and New Zealand, Meritas is represented by leading independent commercial law firms in each of these six major capital cities:

In Australia

Adelaide DMAW Lawyers

Brisbane Bennett & Philp

Melbourne Madgwicks Lawyers

Perth Williams+Hughes

Sydney Swaab  

In New Zealand

Auckland Martelli McKegg

Need a new will ? Witnessing wills during Covid-19 in Western Australia
Post by Damian Quail | Posted 4 years ago on Friday, April 24th, 2020

In Western Australia for a Will to be valid:

  • the Will must be in writing
  • the person making the Will must have "testamentary capacity"
  • the Will must be signed by at least two witnesses in the presence of the person making the Will.

The last requirement may be difficult to satisfy during the Covid-19 emergency period, particularly in places where there are prohibitions on people leaving their homes i.e. lockdowns.

In some jurisdictions, emergency Regulations have been quickly introduced by Governments to get around the difficulty in achieving face to face witnessing. For more details of the approaches taken in New South Wales, Queensland and New Zealand, our associate firms SwaabBennett & Philp and Martelli McKegg have written interesting articles on the subject. Click on their names for more details.

There are no new emergency laws in Western Australia dealing with witnessing of Wills - yet- and so the third requirement still applies. Execution of a Will in Western Australia cannot be witnessed remotely e.g. via videoconference. Similarly, digital signing of a Will is unlikely to be legally effective, and is certainly not advisable.

However, the WA Attorney General the Hon John Quigley MLA has acknowledged the important work of the legal profession, saying in correspondence to the Law Society of Western Australia “I have no doubt that Law Society members are providing essential services to the community during this difficult time.” (more details are here). Further, the West Australian Government’s Prohibition on Regional Travel Directions provides that people performing an "essential service" includes those with specialist skills “required for industry or business continuity and maintenance of competitive operation, where the service is time-critical”.

Our view is that preparing and witnessing Wills is an essential, time critical service, particularly for those concerned about Covid-19. This means that you are able to meet with a solicitor in-person for the purposes of executing a Will. Moreover, in Western Australia strict lockdowns have not been implemented, and so attending your solicitor's office is generally not prohibited. 

Our Perth and Geraldton offices are open for business. Some of our staff are working remotely, and the remainder are working in our offices as usual.

We generally prefer videoconference meetings, for the moment, to take Will instructions. We can organise Skype, Zoom, Blue Jeans, Microsoft Teams, Facetime, Webex or other online meetings as needed. Please note that we cannot take instructions to prepare a Will from a person who is not the person making the Will (the testator), so we must be able to speak with them directly, and preferably alone. We must be able to satisfy ourselves that they are speaking without any pressure or undue influence from someone else. We must also satisfy ourselves that they have sufficient mental capacity to give us Will instructions.

For witnessing Wills, we will work with our clients to satisfy the legal requirement to witness signing of a Will. In this regard, we are complying with the Department of Health's recommended measures to reduce the risk of Covid-19 transmission. These guidelines are being regularly updated as the circumstances evolve, and include practising good hygiene and social distancing.

In some cases, these guidelines will prevent us from being able to witness execution of Wills. In other cases, we can arrange in person witnessing. It is not legally necessary that all signatories use the same pen. It is also not legally necessary that all signatories be physically close to each other - witnessing is valid provided all signatories can see each other sign.  

Of course, anyone required to socially isolate - including those diagnosed with COVID-19, awaiting test results for COVID-19, who have been in close contact with a confirmed case of COVID-19, or who have arrived in Australia after midnight on 15 March 2020 - will not be able to attend our office.

At the time of witnessing a Will, we always need to ensure that a person signing the Will understands what they are signing and are signing of their own free will. This is a legal requirement. 

If a Will cannot be witnessed in compliance with the above legal requirements, it may still be possible to establish the validity of the Will via a Court process.

For further information or to arrange a new Will please contact Michelle Hankey or Cassandra Bailey in our office.

 

This article is general information only, at the date it is posted.  It is not, and should not be relied upon as, legal advice.  This article might not be updated over time and therefore may not reflect changes to the law.  Please feel free to contact us for legal advice that is specific to your situation.

Clarifying the ability of trustees to expand their powers: the decision in Re Application of Country Road Services Pty Ltd
Post by Jonathan Haeusler | Posted 5 years ago on Wednesday, January 29th, 2020

In this article (published in the December 2019 edition of the Law Society Brief magazine) Jonathan Haeusler, Special Counsel, and Michelle Hankey, Solicitor, discuss the court’s decision in Re Application of Country Road Services Pty Ltd [2019] NSWSC 779 regarding a trustee’s role and their ability to expand their powers as trustee. 

The trust instrument that created a trust is the primary source of the trustee’s duties, obligations and powers.  A trustee’s primary duty is to administer the trust in accordance with the terms of the trust instrument.  If a trustee acts outside the terms of the trust instrument, the trustee’s acts will be "ultra vires" i.e. invalid.  In certain circumstances, a trustee may apply to the court for, among other things, an order conferring additional powers on the trustee where it would be “expedient in the management and administration” of the trust property to do so.

However, a trustee cannot seek additional and new powers so that it might administer the trust in a different way from that contemplated in the trust instrument. The trustee should not seek to question the terms of the trust or seek to improve them.

The court’s decision in Re Application of Country Road Services Pty Ltd serves to remind us of the trustee’s function in making applications to the court for orders conferring additional powers on trustees.  In particular, the court’s observations remind us that the trustee’s role is to administer the trust in accordance with the terms of the trust instrument, not to seek to change the trust instrument.  Further, that the usual role of a trustee should be one of neutrality.  

The key take-aways from the court’s decision are set out in Jonathan’s article, which is available here.  

If you have any queries regarding trust administration, please contact Jonathan Haeusler or Michelle Hankey of our office. 

 

This article is general information only, at the date it is posted.  It is not, and should not be relied upon as, legal advice.  This article might not be updated over time and therefore may not reflect changes to the law.  Please feel free to contact us for legal advice that is specific to your situation.

Contested Wills & Estate Litigation

Our relevant and notable experience includes:

Dominique Engelter

Principal

LLB, BA

team-member-image
team-member-image
EXPERIENCE

Dominique specialises in complex dispute resolution in the Western Australian jurisdiction; focused predominantly in the Supreme Court. 

He acts as counsel in trials in both the State and Federal Courts, as well as the State Administrative Tribunal.

Dominique has a broad range of experience across insolvency litigation, mining, commercial lease and property disputes, and trusts and estate litigation acting for: 

  • Land developers, project managers, and engineering companies in Construction Contract Act adjudications. 
  • Liquidators in asset recovery actions and Personal Property Securities Act disputes.   
  • Directors and creditors in defending claims made by liquidators.
  • Mining companies in disputes concerning tenement and plant acquisitions and disposals, tenement expenditure requirements, and contractual disputes in relation to farm-ins and drilling services.
  • Lessors and lessees in commercial tenancy disputes including lessee claims for relief against forfeiture, equitable priorities between competing lessees, disputes concerning valid lease termination and breach of quiet enjoyment.  Two recent examples are
  • Executors and beneficiaries in Family Provision Act claims, proceedings to remove executors/trustees, and Will interpretation cases.
  • Directors, shareholders, and partners in shareholder and partnership disputes, equitable claims such as diversion of commercial opportunities and breach of fiduciary duty, and Corporations Act claims such as breach of directors' duties.

Some examples of Dominique's experience as trial counsel are:

Dominique is a graduate of the Australian Institute of Company Directors (AICD) and a member of AMPLA.

Contested Wills & Estate Litigation

Williams + Hughes provides a complete and integrated service from succession and Estate planning, to the preparation of Wills and associated documents such as testamentary trusts and powers of attorney and guardianship, through to dispute resolution services.

Our litigation team has a broad range of experience assisting Executors/Executrix’, Administrators, and beneficiaries and other claimants, in dealing with claims to prove the validity of Wills, court actions to interpret Will provisions, and claims under the Family Provision Act 1972 (inheritance claims).

We also act in the State Administrative Tribunal in guardianship and financial administration matters.

Click to view

Our relevant and notable experience includes:

  • Acted for a beneficiary in a significant Supreme Court inheritance claim in a deceased Estate with assets of more than $1 billion
  • Acted for the executor in Supreme Court proceedings seeking interpretation of bequests in a Will.  The proceedings also dealt with the Charitable Trusts Act and whether the Court retained an inherent cy-pres power
  • Acted for the executrix to defend Supreme Court proceedings seeking her removal, and concerning the interpretation of clauses in a Will
  • Acted for family members in applications to the State Administrative Tribunal for guardianship and plenary administration powers, and in Supreme Court proceedings by administrators seeking to deal with Estate property
  • Acted for the successful defendant in a Supreme Court family provision claim including a claim of a constructive trust over assets transferred during the deceased's lifetime
  • Acted for a defendant in Supreme Court proceedings regarding a contested Will and Family Provision Act claim for a multi-million dollar Geraldton farming Estate, which was settled by deed of family arrangement
  • Acted for the administrators of a deceased Estate in a claim against the deceased's former solicitor who meddled with the Estate's assets

Litigation & Dispute Resolution Lawyers

Williams + Hughes has a long held reputation as having trusted expert litigation and dispute resolution lawyers in Perth. Our litigation and dispute resolution lawyer team is one of the largest litigation teams in Western Australia, regularly appearing in the State and Federal Courts and the State Administrative Tribunal.

We assist and advise clients on the full range of corporate and commercial litigation and dispute resolution matters. We act for public and private companies and individuals, assisting them to obtain the best outcome possible.

If you are in need of litigation and dispute resolution lawyers in Perth, contact us and see what sets us apart.

Tully Carmady

Principal

LLB

team-member-image
team-member-image
EXPERIENCE

Tully is a specialist commercial litigator with more than 20 years’ experience. He practices almost exclusively in the Supreme and Federal Courts and has been involved, both as counsel and as instructing solicitor, in many trials and interlocutory hearings, including applications for interlocutory injunctions.

Tully is an experienced commercial negotiator and has had great success in resolving disputes for his clients through mediation without the expense and delay of a trial. In the modern commercial litigation practice the ability to negotiate effectively, either at formal mediations or meetings generally, is an essential skill.  Tully believes that you should never lose sight of the end result, the key is to identify the client’s goal, then move to achieve that goal in a commercial and efficient way, but also in a way that is proportionate to the nature of the dispute.

While Tully has a broad range of experience, he has made a particular speciality of disputes involving the breakdown of the relationship between the co-owners of businesses. Whatever the structure – partnership, company or unit trust – he is able to guide his clients through these difficult situations, which generally involve divergent views as to relative contributions and expectations.

Tully is a member of the Law Society of Western Australia and a member of the Australian Institute of Company Directors. Tully is a Director of Williams + Hughes.

Recent litigation matters Tully has conducted in Court include:

 

Pages

Copyright © 2025 Williams+ Hughes. All Rights Reserved | Privacy | Terms & Conditions